Prosecutor: Teen spent months researching how to kill 64-year-old neighbor
By Emily Sanderson
Click here for updates on this story
CINCINNATI (WLWT) — A 14-year-old will be in juvenile detention until he’s 21 after admitting to murdering his 64-year-old neighbor earlier this year in Fairfax.
The incident unfolded late Feb. 1 and into Feb. 2, when officers responded to the home on Germania Street for a report of an unresponsive woman.
Police say officers and medical personnel confirmed the woman, later identified as 64-year-old Sheila “Denise” Tenpenny, was dead.
Tenpenny’s brother found his sister dead inside her home. He called 911.
“I think my sister’s been murdered,” he said. “She’s got her head covered with a pillow, her legs exposed.”
Ten days after Tenpenny was found dead, investigators announced her 13-year-old neighbor was charged with murder.
In court Monday, the teen admitted to charges of aggravated murder, aggravated burglary and strangulation. In exchange, the serious youthful offender indictment and remaining six charges will be dismissed.
Prosecutor Linda Scott said months prior to the incident, the teen “researched how to strangle someone, how to do it, how to find a victim.”
“For months the defendant did this sort of research,” Scott said in court.
According to Scott, the teen went to the victim’s home, found her sleeping, struck her and suffocated her.
Scott said the victim fought throughout this struggle, caused injury to the teen’s face, and was even found to be holding his hair when she was discovered. The teen’s blood was also found throughout her house and his watch under her body.
Scott said after the incident, the teen “notified social media” saying “this one was a fighter.”
Investigators followed the DNA to the teen, ultimately leading to his arrest.
Agent Ward with the Bureau of Criminal Investigations also talked about the premeditation of the offense and posts to social media. Ward said the teen also searched “how to defeat police interrogation” and communicated with others during the investigation, saying things like “I think I just got caught.”
“It’s very disturbing,” Ward said. “My fear is he made mistakes, but in the future is will he learn from those mistakes.”
Ward says his team is looking into the people the teen was communicating with, including one person they believe is overseas.
Ward said in his 25 years, he’s never seen premeditation like this with someone the teen’s age.
The family of the victim read statements at the hearing, saying how much the murder impacted their lives
“She was the one I could confide in when I thought there wasn’t anyone,” a statement from one of Tenpenny’s nieces read. “Nothing will replace what was taken from us. How are we supposed to just move forward?”
“What you did was not an accident, it was deliberate and it was planned. You chose her because you thought she was alone and no one would notice or care. You were wrong. She was deeply loved,” a statement from one of Tenpenny’s nieces said. “You thought no one would grieve her, instead you shattered an entire circle of people.”
“My sister was a good woman. She never hurt anyone. She lived a quiet, peaceful life and yet her life was stolen in the most violent, senseless way possible,” Tenpenny’s sister said in court. “This was a deliberate and heartless act that took the life of someone who deserved nothing but kindness. My sister deserved to live and we deserve justice.”
As part of the plea agreement, the teen was sentenced to “juvy life” meaning he will remain in juvenile detention until he’s 21. The teen was also given a stay away order, ordering him not to contact the victim’s family in any way.
The plea agreement also means the teen can’t request early release, as it will be denied.
“I think it’s new, different and unprecedented to deal with a 13-year-old who just admitted to aggravated murder,” Public defender Travis Dunnington said in court.”I think the guiding principle is that acts, committed especially at this young age, do not have to define who you will always be,” the teen’s attorney stated in court.
While in juvenile detention, the teen was also ordered to complete his education, earning his high school diploma.
This story was provided to CNN Wire by an affiliate partner and does not contain original CNN reporting.
Please note: This content carries a strict local market embargo. If you share the same market as the contributor of this article, you may not use it on any platform.








