Mistrial declared in Brawley double murder trial

Jessamyn Dodd

IMPERIAL COUNTY, Calif. (KYMA) – A mistrial was declared Tuesday in the trial for a man charged with the double murder of a Brawley couple.

This comes a day after the jury was unable to reach an agreement to find Brandon Hamlin, 28, guilty of either first-degree or second-degree murder.

“In a situation like that, becausethey can’t decide on the degree of murder….we had the option of either having them get a verdict of second degree murder, which would have given him 30 years to life,” said George Marquez, Imperial County District Attorney. “At that point, we decided to do the trial again. That’s an option we have as the DA’s Office.”

District Attorney George Marquez said his office had the option of accepting a second degree charge, but wanted to push for a first degree verdict.

Last Friday, the jury requested additional transcripts of Hamlin confessing to the murders during a police interrogation, and to his grandfather in a jailhouse phone call.

Hamlin is charged with the double murder of Elia, 78, and Rigoberto Castro, 84, in Brawley in 2023.

Both the defense and prosecution stated that Hamlin is guilty of murder during the first trial.

Marquez said he believes this case deserves a first-degree murder conviction, and now, he said his office is preparing again.

“We’re just trying to make sure our expert witnesses are available, especially the pathologist. And we have some out of state witnesses that we need to make sure are available,” Marquez shared.

Hamlin, who will remain in custody at the Imperial County Jail, will be back in court at the end of the month, where the prosecution and defense will decide on a new trial date.

Click here to follow the original article.