What’s behind the $90,000 disagreement keeping the Palm Springs Film Festival out of Festival Theaters?

Raymond Kalra

PALM SPRINGS, Calif. (KESQ) – A financial disagreement involving an additional $90,000 has left one of Palm Springs’ longtime movie theaters out of next year’s Palm Springs International Film Festival. But despite the failed negotiations, representatives from both organizations say they hope to work together again.

In exclusive interviews with News Channel 3 on Thursday, Palm Springs International Film Society Executive Director Toni Merrihew and Festival Theaters General Manager Zack Solomon shared their perspectives on the negotiations, the financial challenges facing both organizations, and what the decision could mean moving forward.

The interviews also revealed new details about the involvement of a Palm Springs city councilmember who attempted to help the two sides reach an agreement.

How the $90,000 disagreement unfolded

According to Merrihew, the film society began discussions with Festival Theaters several months ago about securing the venue for the January 2027 festival.

Unlike some longstanding partnerships, Merrihew said the festival does not have a multiyear agreement with the theater, requiring the organizations to negotiate terms for each festival.

She said her team worked with theater representatives to develop an offer that included more cash than the organization had paid in previous years, along with sponsorship benefits intended to appeal to theater ownership.

“We increased the cash that we were going to pay for the venue that we’ve done over previous years, and we put together a package of sponsorship benefits that we were told the owner would be interested in,” Merrihew explained.

The film society submitted a nonbinding term sheet outlining the proposed agreement. Merrihew said several weeks passed without a clear response.

With festival programmers needing to secure screening locations and finalize scheduling, the organization began exploring alternative venues.

When theater ownership eventually responded, Merrihew said the counterproposal included a request for an additional $90,000 in cash, along with more extensive sponsorship benefits.

“The additional 90,000 was an ask,” Merrihew said. “So after we finally got a response back from the theater owner, that was the additional ask.”

Merrihew said she does not know what the additional money was intended to cover, explaining that the question would need to be answered by theater ownership.

By that point, festival organizers had already begun making arrangements elsewhere.

“We couldn’t absorb that additional 90,000,” Merrihew said. “We relayed that that was probably non-negotiable.”

Questions about the festival’s financial health

The disagreement also raises questions about the financial pressures facing the nonprofit film society.

When asked whether the inability to absorb an additional $90,000 raised concerns about the festival’s financial stability, Merrihew said the organization is currently in a healthy position but has faced challenges in previous years.

“The festival is healthy right now and we’re proud of that,” she said.

Merrihew acknowledged that the festival has operated at a loss for many years, while emphasizing that the film society is a nonprofit supporting numerous community and educational programs.

Those initiatives include free community screenings, student screening days, filmmaker education opportunities and programs connecting filmmakers with classrooms.

She explained that accepting the additional expense could affect funding available for those programs.

With operating costs increasing, Merrihew said the organization must carefully evaluate its budget each year.

A Palm Springs councilmember’s involvement

Merrihew also revealed that a Palm Springs city councilmember became involved in efforts to negotiate an agreement between the festival and theater ownership.

During her on-camera interview, she described the councilmember as an advocate attempting to help the two sides reach a resolution.

“It’s really a challenge when you have somebody outside of the festival working with somebody else because they don’t understand what we can or can’t do,” Merrihew said.

She explained that discussions involving an outside party can create complications when potential agreements or financial arrangements still need approval from the festival itself.

However, Merrihew also credited the councilmember for attempting to help.

“I think that the council member, you know, made best efforts,” she said.

Following the on-camera interview, Merrihew identified that councilmember to News Channel 3, on the record, as Ron deHarte.

Merrihew did not explicitly accuse deHarte of causing negotiations to collapse. She said the theater’s ownership ultimately did not find the proposed arrangements workable, while the festival had progressed too far with alternative plans to continue pursuing an agreement for 2027.

News Channel 3 reached out to deHarte and City of Palm Springs officials seeking clarification about the city’s involvement in negotiations and what efforts were made to reach an agreement.

News Channel 3 also sought comment from theater owner Dale Okuno regarding the additional $90,000 requested and the financial considerations behind that proposal.

No responses had been received from deHarte, city officials or ownership as of publication.

What losing the festival means for Festival Theaters

While the financial disagreement has attracted attention, Festival Theaters General Manager Zack Solomon said the theater had been looking forward to welcoming the film festival back in January.

“We were definitely relying or at least not relying, but definitely hoping to have the festival here in January,” Solomon said. “It was looking to be a really good month.”

Solomon, who previously worked with the Palm Springs International Film Festival, said hosting major events provides financial benefits and introduces new audiences to the theater’s programming.

He acknowledged that operating an independent movie theater has been challenging, particularly when it comes to encouraging moviegoers to attend screenings throughout the year.

“It has been a struggle,” Solomon said.

He explained that the theater has been working to establish itself as a destination for independent, foreign and first-run films, alongside major commercial releases.

According to Solomon, ticket sales from commercial movies help support the theater’s more specialized programming, including filmmaker appearances, discussions and independent screenings.

The theater has also been exploring opportunities for additional amenities, potentially including a cafe and bar.

Despite losing the anticipated festival business in January, Solomon expressed confidence about the theater’s immediate future.

“We’ll be okay in the short term, and I just hope that we can find a way to bridge the gap,” he said.

Solomon did not address the specific financial negotiations involving theater ownership during his interview.

Instead, he emphasized his continued support for the film festival and its organizers.

“I’ve worked for the festival for a long time. I believe they’re going to have successful festival this year. I wish them really well,” Solomon said.

Could the festival return in 2028?

Despite the disagreement, both organizations say they would like to continue their longstanding relationship.

Merrihew praised Festival Theaters’ staff and emphasized that the film society has no desire to see the theater struggle.

She said the film society continues to work with Festival Theaters on other programming, including member screenings.

“My goal is that hopefully we can come together in January or February of next year and start figuring out what next year’s, the 2028 festival, is going to look like,” Merrihew said.

Solomon expressed similar hopes, saying he would welcome an opportunity to work together again for ShortFest in summer 2027 or a future edition of the international film festival.

“I really hope that this is a blip and something that happens one year and hopefully it doesn’t happen again,” he said.

In the meantime, the 2027 Palm Springs International Film Festival is moving forward with screenings at other venues across the Coachella Valley.

Merrihew said the festival will have an expanded presence at the historic Plaza Theatre in downtown Palm Springs, along with screenings at venues including the Annenberg Theater, Palm Springs Cultural Center and Palm Canyon Theatre.

She stressed that losing one screening location does not mean the festival is leaving Palm Springs, noting that opening night, closing night and festival parties will remain in the city.

For now, questions remain about what the additional $90,000 requested by theater ownership would have covered and whether the two organizations can reach a future agreement.

Both Merrihew and Solomon say they remain hopeful that the partnership can eventually resume.

News Channel 3 will continue following this story and seeking responses from theater ownership and city officials.

This is a developing story. Stay with News Channel 3 for updates.

Click here to follow the original article.