Serial killer Fredrick Scott found guilty in four of six deaths along Indian Creek Trail
By JoBeth Davis
Click here for updates on this story
KANSAS CITY, Missouri (KMBC) — A jury has found Fredrick Scott guilty of murder in four of six deaths, in a verdict Tuesday.
The jury announced guilty verdicts against Scott in four of the murder charges and four of the armed criminal action charges.
Scott was charged with six counts of first-degree murder and six counts of armed criminal action in connection with the deaths of David Lenox, Timothy Rice, Mike Darby, John Palmer, Karen Harmeyer and Steven Gibbons.
Scott was ultimately found not guilty in the deaths of David Lenox and Timothy Rice.
Most of the deaths happened along Kansas City’s Indian Creek Trail.
After a several-week trial, jurors received the case and began deliberating Thursday.
A long process led up to the trial, including work to establish competency so that Scott could face a jury in connection with the deaths.
“It’s been a long time coming, and while justice can sometimes be delayed, I’m very grateful for the majority of the families that today justice was not denied,” said Jackson County Prosecutor Melesa Johnson. “Of course my thoughts and prayers continue to be with the Rice and Lenox families, but this is the process, and I’m very proud of our trial team.
“I’m so proud of our trial team in this office for seeing every step of the way through over a decade, and now … to these families, maybe closing the chapter of this incident, but we understand that the chapter of grief is never closed.”
Johnson said prosecutors would ask for a life sentence in prison without the possibility of parole for Scott.
The jury recommended a now-convicted serial killer spend the rest of his life in prison without the possibility of probation or parole.
The jury recommended the life sentences for each murder conviction and 15 years in prison for each of the four armed criminal action convictions.
“He will never be out again. He will never hunt again,” said Brian Darby.
Nine years ago, Scott fatally shot Brian’s father, Mike Darby, in the back of the head as Mike was walking his dogs along the Indian Creek Trail.
Prosecutors said Scott stalked, targeted, and then shot and killed five random white middle-aged men he didn’t know at or near the Indian Creek Trail in 2016 and 2017.
In his police interview, Scott said, “They never saw it coming.”
Scott also killed homeless woman Karen Harmeyer in Grandview who was also white.
He didn’t know her either.
When asked if these murders might be racially motivated, Jackson County Prosecutor Melesa Johnson said, “We have no evidence of that.”
The jury found Scott guilty of the murders of John Palmer, Mike Darby, Karen Harmeyer, and Steven Gibbons.
The jury found Scott not guilty for the David Lenox and Timothy Rice murders.
The jury deliberated for only a few minutes on the Scott sentencing recommendations.
Before the deliberations, seven family members of Michael Darby and John Palmer gave victim impact statements.
Darby’s brother Bob called Michael the best man he’s ever known and his best friend.
Palmer’s widow Catherine said she felt like she was torn in half after John’s murder and said it’s been a struggle to get back to a normal life.
The convictions come after years of legal wrangling.
Scott’s attorneys argued their client was mentally ill and not competent to stand trial.
Nearly a decade of rulings on that competency issue came before Scott went to trial.
Scott is scheduled to be formally sentenced November 23.
In the meantime, he’s being held in the Jackson County Jail without the possibility of release.
Count I: First-degree murder – John Palmer – GUILTY Count II: Armed criminal action in John Palmer death – GUILTY Count III: First-degree murder – David Lenox – NOT GUILTY Count IV: Armed criminal action in David Lenox death – NOT GUILTY Count V: First-degree murder – Timothy Rice – NOT GUILTY Count VI: Armed criminal action in Timothy Rice death – NOT GUILTY Count VII: First-degree murder – Michael Darby – GUILTY Count VIII: Armed criminal action in Michael Darby death – GUILTY County IX: First-degree murder – Karen Harmeyer – GUILTY Count X: Armed criminal action in Karen Harmeyer death – GUILTY Count XI: First-degree murder – Steve Gibbons – GUILTY Count XII: Armed criminal action in Steve Gibbons death – GUILTY
Please note: This story was provided to CNN Wire by an affiliate and does not contain original CNN reporting. This content carries a strict local market embargo. If you share the same market as the contributor of this article, you may not use it on any platform.







